BRIEFING: "China's economy: Not just another fake; The similarities between China today and Japan in the 1980s may look ominous But China's boom is unlikely to give way to prolonged slump," The Economist, 16 January 2010.
COMMENT: "What we can learn from Japan's decades of trouble," by Martin Wolf, Financial Times, 13 January 2010.
Similarities: extreme savings rate, undervalued currency, export-driven growth, and huge current-account surplus with chronic overinvestment (meaning loads of bad loans) and overvalued real estate.
Thus we get hedge fund guy James Chanos arguing China's crash will be Dubai times 1,000 or worse!
But when you look at the three key concerns (overvalued assets, overinvestment and excessive bank lending), China doesn't actually look so bad--or at least not as bad as Japan was back before the fall.
Stock prices: Japan's had a price-earning ratio of about 70, while Shanghai's class A stocks sit at 28 (with its long run average being 37).
Yes the housing market is hot, but relative to income growth in China, it trails. Yes, the average cost of a house is ten times annual income, whereas in the U.S. it's typically 4-5. But Chinese homebuyers come from the richest ranks, so the average misleads here, because when the urban elite are compared (and there are numerous), they come very close to the Western average.
Plus, the Chinese tend to pay cash and have small mortgages, so the boom is financed more by savings than by banks.
As for overinvestment, even now the capital stock per person in China is only about 5% that of the U.S. or Japan, so room to grow!
Does China allocate capital well, or is it a modern, marketized version of the USSR with too much meddling from the middle? The mag discounts this too, but here I personally do worry. I've never seen a bunch of guys sitting around the table beat the market's comprehensive wisdom or ruthlessness day-in and day-out. Extensive growth must increasingly be replaced by intensive growth in China, so I wouldn't be surprised that there's tons of bad investments.
The biggest worry, says the Economist, is the recent wave of sloppy bank stimulus lending. Total credit jumped by 30% last year, so you know bad decisions were made.
Optimistic take? The percentage of bad loans in China is unlikely to jump much, so bearable.
Can the bubble burst? Of course!
We're just not looking for a long slump to follow, ala Japan.
But Wolf's point on Japan is key: excessive corporate savings plus diminished investment opportunities (once all the extensive, "catch-up" growth was achieved) did Japan in, and eventually, say I, China will logically hit a similar point where it will pay for political rigidity.