Buy Tom's Books
  • Great Powers: America and the World After Bush
    Great Powers: America and the World After Bush
    by Thomas P.M. Barnett
  • Blueprint for Action: A Future Worth Creating
    Blueprint for Action: A Future Worth Creating
    by Thomas P.M. Barnett
  • The Pentagon's New Map: War and Peace in the Twenty-first Century
    The Pentagon's New Map: War and Peace in the Twenty-first Century
    by Thomas P.M. Barnett
  • Romanian and East German Policies in the Third World: Comparing the Strategies of Ceausescu and Honecker
    Romanian and East German Policies in the Third World: Comparing the Strategies of Ceausescu and Honecker
    by Thomas P.M. Barnett
  • The Emily Updates (Vol. 1): One Year in the Life of the Girl Who Lived (The Emily Updates (Vols. 1-5))
    The Emily Updates (Vol. 1): One Year in the Life of the Girl Who Lived (The Emily Updates (Vols. 1-5))
    by Vonne M. Meussling-Barnett, Thomas P.M. Barnett
  • The Emily Updates (Vol. 2): One Year in the Life of the Girl Who Lived (The Emily Updates (Vols. 1-5))
    The Emily Updates (Vol. 2): One Year in the Life of the Girl Who Lived (The Emily Updates (Vols. 1-5))
    by Thomas P.M. Barnett, Vonne M. Meussling-Barnett
  • The Emily Updates (Vol. 3): One Year in the Life of the Girl Who Lived (The Emily Updates (Vols. 1-5))
    The Emily Updates (Vol. 3): One Year in the Life of the Girl Who Lived (The Emily Updates (Vols. 1-5))
    by Thomas P.M. Barnett, Vonne M. Meussling-Barnett
  • The Emily Updates (Vol. 4): One Year in the Life of the Girl Who Lived (The Emily Updates (Vols. 1-5))
    The Emily Updates (Vol. 4): One Year in the Life of the Girl Who Lived (The Emily Updates (Vols. 1-5))
    by Thomas P.M. Barnett, Vonne M. Meussling-Barnett
  • The Emily Updates (Vol. 5): One Year in the Life of the Girl Who Lived (The Emily Updates (Vols. 1-5))
    The Emily Updates (Vol. 5): One Year in the Life of the Girl Who Lived (The Emily Updates (Vols. 1-5))
    by Vonne M. Meussling-Barnett, Thomas P.M. Barnett, Emily V. Barnett
Search the Site
Powered by Squarespace
Monthly Archives
11:39PM

The drone kills: yes, it makes me more careful in criticizing Israel

U.S. NEWS: "Drone Kills Suspect in CIA Suicide Bombing: Agency Hits Back After December Deaths of Seven Agents; Panetta and McChrystal See Pressure Rising on al Qaeda, Taliban," by Siobhan Gorman and Jonathan Weisman, Wall Street Journal, 18 March 2010.

Tell me how this differs from the storyline of "Munich": You kill ours and we hunt you down and kill your perpetrators with no effort at a judicial proceeding.

I try to remember that when things like the recent Dubai hit are debated.

This remains a mafia-style decapitation war. I don't have a problem with that. But the reality of this pot should be remembered when discussing the kettle that is Israel.

1:47PM

Tom around the web

+ Musing 5GW mentioned Tom.
+ The League of Ordinary Gentlemen quoted Tom: "America is modern globalization's source-code".
+ Paul Musgrave reviewed GP.
+ The Pilgrim Sailor linked Wal-Mart exports rules to China.
+ KoopTech linked The Map.

9:18AM

Tom on the strategic logic of U.S. military facilities around the Gap/Colombia

ARTICLE: 'US-Colombia military base pact is misunderstood', By Brett Borkan, Colombia Reports, 19 March 2010

The whole thing is an interview with Tom, so please go check it out.

Tom writes:

Only quibble I make: I told him upfront I was not an expert on Colombia or our cooperation there but that I could only respond in a general strategic sense. I would have liked to see that disclaimer made up front. But otherwise very happy with the translation made on an over-the-phone interview.

12:10AM

Obama's hurry to leave Afghanistan precludes strategic imagination

OP-ED: Why the U.S. must talk to the Taliban, By Ahmed Rashid, Washington Post, March 18, 2010

Nice piece by Rashid, that underlies the regional concerns over the situation that Team Obama seems to be shaping up as their leave-behind -- namely, the same old, same old of Pakistan domination from the South via the Taliban.

Key para:

India, Iran and Russia have long been averse to any dialogue with the Taliban that could give Pakistan greater leverage in the region or with Washington. All see the various extremist groups based in Pakistan as threats to their security. India is working to rebuild the regional alliance that opposed the Taliban and Pakistan in the 1990s. Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin visited India last Thursday, partly to discuss a common strategy on a post-U.S. Afghanistan. Senior Indian officials have met with Karzai in Kabul and are due in Iran later this month.

The possibility worth noting? Another Mumbai-like attack that puts India and Pakistan on a war-footing with each other.

The reason why Rashid says talk now is that the regional players are all seeking to influence the outcome--outside of any U.S. effort, and so most of the die will already be cast if we don't seek out the Taliban dialogue soon.

I must admit, the whole approach of the Obama administration disappoints. No strategic imagination here whatsoever, and Holbrooke seems marginal--as does Clinton. We seek merely to fix the situation up in the South just enough to leave, meaning we end up relying on Pakistan to the dissatisfaction of everybody in the region--except for Pakistan.

I still hold out some hope for a more regionalized approach, but I'm seeing and hearing nothing to that effect.

(Thanks: Our man in Kabul))

12:05AM

Iraq election aftermath

ARTICLE: Iraq Elections: Maliki's Path to Re-election, By Kirk Sowell, World Politics Review, 16 Mar 2010

ARTICLE: Followers of Sadr Emerge Stronger After Iraq Elections,
By ANTHONY SHADID, New York Times, March 16, 2010

Very nice piece of analysis by Sowell.

Presumed outcome is Maliki + Kurds + non-Sadr Shiite Islamists = coalition, with Sadr spoiling ineffectively and the Sunnis living with minority political status.

Thus:

Assuming the most likely scenario, the election's outcome will most benefit Arab-Kurd relations on the national level, and Iraq's oil industry. In light of Kurdish leverage over Maliki, the long-awaited national oil law could be near (even if a Kirkuk compromise may be too much to hope for), and Maliki's re-election means the companies that won last December's licensing round will breathe easier. But look for a deterioration of provincial-level Arab-Kurd relations, as Sunni Arabs in Ninawa, Kirkuk and Diyala fear they will be marginalized by another Shiite-Kurd government.

Of my scenarios offered in the WPR column a while back, the Big Oil Wins seems most operative. Federalism survives, Iran's influence seems intact but not particularly increased, and democracy looks about as good as it gets in this region.

Shadid's piece, in contrast, portrays the Sadrists as just as big a kingmaker as the Kurds, and with Allawi, according to CNN just now (17 Mar) edging ahead of Maliki, maybe the PM will need them more.

12:02AM

Why Iran is so attractive as a market: the workaround skills of the population

WORLD NEWS: "Iranians switch to informal saving funds as loans dry up," by Najmeh Bozorgmehr, Financial Times, 13-14 March 2010.

People and businesses spontaneously pooling resources and organizing themselves as loan-sharing services--sort of mutual micro-lending that gets around the increasingly isolated and sanctioned banking system.

It's a sign of ever-deepening stagnation, of course (which is why I find all this "Iran is getting stronger!" stuff to be nonsense), but something to remember when the connectivity breakthrough finally comes. This is one skillful and resilient population.

11:17PM

The al-Qaeda-after-next is not to be feared, merely scheduled

SECURITY | ISLAM: "Terror Has a New Name; Lashkar-e-Taiba--the Pakistani militant group that perpetrated the 2008 Mumbai attacks--Is Getting Ready to Go Global," by Jeremy Kahn, Newsweek, 15 March 2010.

The roster is always going to be shifting.

That's why we call it the long war.

How long? Until globalization is truly global--simple as that.

11:15PM

Transparency for the Chinese taxpayer?

WORLD NEWS: "Activists Test Beijing Openness Vow," by Shai Oster, Wall Street Journal, 11 March 2010.

Very sensible and positive sign: some cities and provinces starting to bow to popular pressure, with some approval from Beijing, to publish public finances, long considered a state secret (the usual BS that hides mucho corruption).

Sichuan quake was a driver here, as well it should have been.

China passed a freedom-of-info-like act in May 2008 to please the WTO. Naturally, it's a weakly enforced piece of paper, and yet, more and more activists are working hard to exploit it.

One guy, Wu Junliang, helped open up Shenzen city's budget, declaring that he did so because "I'm trying to raise taxpayers' consciousness" by showing where their money is going.

Gotta love that.

Another big push factor: the clearly over-budget Three Gorges dam project, estimated at $8B in 1992. Last year the government admitted it's more like $37B now, and critics say the truth is more like $75B. Why the secrecy? Beijing would have to explain how government and party officials siphoned off so much money.

All good stuff. Unreasonable individuals leading the way!

12:58AM

India's foreign policy exceeds ours

ARTICLE: India Looks to Deepen Its Afghan Presence, By Priyanka Bhardwaj, World Politics Review, 18 Mar 2010

Well, I recently blogged a piece that suggested India was scaling down. This one on WPR says otherwise, at least in the title, but doesn't exactly sell me going forward since all the examples of development effort were seemingly long or already underway and the major uptick was described as being more security personnel for Indian nationals working there. So if this story counters the previous one, it does so only in the sense of suggesting that India, while not particularly deepening its presence all that much, won't be drawing down either.

I guess I would say India is "hardening" its presence more than deepening.

I will say that I like India's moves to jump-start a regional approach:

This explains New Delhi's recent push for greater international cooperation, with the inclusion of Russia and Iran, to reinvigorate efforts at arriving at an appropriate regional mechanism to tackle growing fundamentalism throughout the region.

I also like her logic on the way forward:

Thus, in the overall context of coming under increasing attack in Afghanistan, India will need to combine its goal of becoming a major stakeholder in that country's stabilization with several concrete measures to raise Pakistan's confidence about its presence. To begin with, New Delhi must make its development work in Afghanistan more transparent. In addition, a constant, formal and wide-ranging engagement with Islamabad on issues relating to Afghanistan will be required.

India must also harmonize its desire for the total elimination of the Taliban in Afghanistan with the emerging international consensus calling for a political resolution to Afghanistan's civil war. To this end, Afghan President Hamid Karzai will likely try to maintain friendly ties with India as a potential counterweight to Pakistan's historic relations with the Taliban, while remaining committed to preventing any proxy wars being staged in his country.

Finding the necessary balance, and thereafter maintaining it, will be a challenge for all three countries.

Smart piece. My optimism is somewhat restored, although I'm embarrassed to see India pursuing the foreign policy that should be our own--aggressive regionalization of the issue.

(Thanks: Our man in Kabul)

12:55AM

China: the princelings are a nice big, fat target of populism

WORLD NEWS: "Enrichment of Chinese officials' children seen as source of popular discontent," by Jamil Anderlini, Financial Times, 13-14 March 2010.

China's former--and well-respected--state auditor (Mr. Li Jinhua) says that the business dealings of the children of Party officials is becoming the main source of public anger toward the state. Party officials, it is estimated, benefit indirectly through "various shades of illegal income streams."

The solution, as always, is better rules:

"I feel our country's legal system has not yet been fully constructed and many legal definitions are not clear," Mr. Li said.

The funny kicker? The publishing paper of record (People's Daily) is suspected of pushing the subject as part of their subscription drive!

12:51AM

Good dissection of underlying struggle in Turkey

COMMENT: "Turkey needs more from Ataturk's irrelevant heirs," by David Gardner, Financial Times, 12 March 2010.

Just a solid piece that gives me the contextual overview I've been craving on the whole AK Party-versus-the-Turkish-military story.

The usual story in Europe is that Turkey is struggling to locate its identity as it works to meet criteria for entry into the EU, thus the need to show the military is properly housebroken.

But since those negotiations have stalled, despite Turkey's heroic efforts to conform, Gardner locates a different struggle: the more sophisticated urban middle class, long represented by the Kemalist parties, fears the rise of the grubbier, lower-middle class cohort from the countryside (meaning anywhere outside of Istanbul, apparently), which sides with the AK Party (usually described as Islamist).

Sounds vaguely blue state v. red state, does it not?

Gardner's basic point: the Kemalist parties are rudderless, while the AK Party continues its sophisticated balancing act:

The AKP, by contrast, is demonstrably the chosen path to modernity of the socially conservative, observant but at the same time dynamic and entrepreneurial middle classes of central Anatolia, who now demand their rightful share of power. The AKP's appeal, in other words, is both aspirational and reassuring, by holding fast to the moorings of family, religion and the villages from which many Turks are just a generation away.

Sounds like a winning hand to me. I mean, I can't come up with a better description of the sort of political movement that successfully navigates an Islamic population from Gap to Core status, something I think the AK Party has already achieved--thus the popular trust factor.

In the end, Turkey don't need no stinkin' badges!

12:50AM

The Economist on containing Iran

UNITED STATES: "Foreign policy: Containing Iran; The president is trapped between an angry Congress and a stubborn China," The Economist< 13 March 2010.

More exploration of the inevitability of America learning to contain a nuclear Iran.

Yes, the GOP will claim, in infinite stupidity, that Obama "gave Iran the bomb," just like Truman was blamed for "losing China"--another beyond brain-dead statement.

No worries: it will balance the untruthfulness of Obama's great "victories" in Iraq and Afghanistan.

12:03AM

India and Russia growing nervous over Obama's Afghanistan strategy

WORLD NEWS: "India tells Putin of Afghan fears: Moscow urged to refocus on Kabul; Singh keen to curb Pakistan influence," by James Lamont, Financial Times, 13-14 March 2010.

The regional powers surrounding Afghanistan are trading notes on what will need to be done once the U.S. is gone, the assumption being that Obama is committed to leaving--as evidenced by the deepening embrace of Pakistan, which in turn is smart enough to deliver in the short run, feeding Washington's impression that this is all going well.

India is proposing that Russia join it, Iran and the Central Asian states in a hedging strategy of the sort that, not all that long ago, had them all supporting the Northern Alliance versus the Pakistani-backed Taliban.

Hard to see this not happening again. And when it does, Obama will be condemned for merely recreating the pre-9/11 standoff.

Compared to the stunningly different Iraq we see today, that will make the war effort seem like a complete waste.

11:56PM

Spirituality eclipsing religion

OP-ED: Spirit Quest, By CHARLES M. BLOW, New York Times, February 19, 2010

The gist:

A report entitled " Religion Among the Millennials" produced by the Pew Research Center's Forum on Religion and Public Life and released this week found that one in four people 18 to 29 years old are unaffiliated with a religion. But that by no means makes them all atheists or agnostics. While there are always religious people among the unaffiliated, the numbers are significantly higher among the younger unaffiliated crowd. While they are less likely than those unaffiliated and older than them to believe in God, they are more likely to believe in life after death, heaven and hell, and miracles.

So, anyone laboring under the delusion that the generation weaned on MTV would move us closer to being weaned of an abnormally high level of religiosity -- at least when compared with other industrialized countries -- may have to keep waiting.

In fact, on some measures, the data suggest that these so-called millennials may be more spiritually thirsty than older generations.

Find this true in my own family: what a complete bitch to keep my older kids Catholic enough to get them through Confirmation, but it's clear that the spirituality is there and growing. It's just not being answered particularly well by the chosen vessel.

All part of the Prothero/"Religious Illiteracy" argument: Americans become more faithful over time, just less specific about it.

Is this bad? Only if you think every answer for today's world can be found in the Bible.

Me personally, I have more faith in God's creations (humans) than any one historical snapshot of that faith's evolution. In general, I love our ability to adapt ourselves to a changing environment, and I think that human quality will be ever more important across this century.

Bottom line: religions are in for a lot of systemic challenges and change across this century, but spirituality will most definitely expand as life grows more complex and people seek moral handholds--a big theme of Great Powers.

11:10PM

OTH recon with SysAdmin blimps

ARTICLE: Military seeks an intelligence-gathering airship, By Walter Pincus, Washington Post, February 16, 2010

How very SysAdmin: the ability to project persistent transparency over a chunk of the Gap using 21st-century "blimps."

Another step in the evolution of the force toward the enduring realities of Gap shrinkage.

11:08PM

Swine flu didn't reach feared heights

ARTICLE: Almost 1 in 5 Americans had swine flu; death rate over 11,000, By David Brown, Washington Post, February 13, 2010

While I suspect the one-in-five understates, it would be hard to argue against the 11,000 total being about one-third the usual flu toll.

Primary reason why the death total didn't reach the predicted heights? Gotta believe it was a combination of good care and the fact that the number of self-immolating cases (where the immune system gets too turned-on and ends up killing the patient) were not nearly as plentiful as feared.

11:02PM

Congrats, Michal

Long-time reader/commenter Michal Shapiro's music blog is now appearing on Huffington Post. We congratulate her on the profile elevation. She deserves it.

11:00PM

Back to the future: African centrality

ARTICLE: How Africa is Becoming the New Asia, By Jerry Guo, NEWSWEEK, Feb 19, 2010

The gist:

China and India get all the headlines for their economic prowess, but there's another global growth story that is easily overlooked: Africa. In 2007 and 2008, southern Africa, the Great Lakes region of Kenya, Tanzania, and Uganda, and even the drought-stricken Horn of Africa had GDP growth rates on par with Asia's two powerhouses. Last year, in the depths of global recession, the continent clocked almost 2 percent growth, roughly equal to the rates in the Middle East, and outperforming everywhere else but India and China. This year and in 2011, Africa will grow by 4.8 percent--the highest rate of growth outside Asia, and higher than even the oft-buzzed-about economies of Brazil, Russia, Mexico, and Eastern Europe, according to newly revised IMF estimates. In fact, on a per capita basis, Africans are already richer than Indians, and a dozen African states have higher gross national income per capita than China.

Of course, comparing the two sides is a bit misleading, because much of the current growth in Africa is due to the resource draw coming from India and China, so they're intimately linked.

But remember, the real power is demand, not Africa's supply of raw materials, and here's where we find the good, good stuff (to quote the B-52s in a rather racy song):

In the last four years, the surge in private consumption of goods and services has accounted for two thirds of Africa's GDP growth. The rapidly emerging African middle class could number as many as 300 million, out of a total population of 1 billion, according to development expert Vijay Majahan, author of the 2009 book Africa Rising. While few of them have the kind of disposable income found in Asia and the West, these accountants, teachers, maids, taxi drivers, even roadside street vendors, are driving up demand for goods and services like cell phones, bank accounts, upmarket foodstuffs, and real estate. In fact, in Africa's 10 largest economies, the service sector makes up 40 percent of GDP, not too far from India's 53 percent. "The new Africa story is consumption," says Graham Thomas, head of principal investment at Standard Bank Group, which operates in 17 African countries.

Then note the strong connectivity flavor to the enduring growth:

Much of the boom in this new consumer class can be attributed to outside forces: evolving trade patterns, particularly from increased demand coming out of China, and technological innovation abroad that spurs local productivity and growth like the multibillion-dollar fiber-optic lines that are being laid out between Africa and the developed world. Other changes are domestic and deliberate. Despite Africa's well-founded reputation for corruption and poor governance, a substantial chunk of the continent has quietly experienced this economic renaissance by dint of its virtually unprecedented political stability. Spurred by eager investors, governments have steadily deregulated industries and developed infrastructure. As a result, countries such as Kenya and Botswana now boast privately owned world-class hospitals, charter schools, and toll roads that are actually safe to drive on. A study by a World Bank program, the Africa Infrastructure Country Diagnostic, found that improvements in Africa's telecom infrastructure have contributed as much as 1 percent to per capita GDP growth, a bigger role than changes in monetary or fiscal policies. Shares of stocks in recently privatized local airlines, freight companies, and telecoms have skyrocketed.

This includes people connections:

Entrepreneurship has increased at the same time, powered in part by the influx of returning skilled workers. Just as waves of expats returned to China and India in the 1990s to start businesses that in turn attracted more outside talent and capital, there are now signs that an entrepreneurial African diaspora will help transform the continent.

Now I've basically excerpted the entire front half of the piece, except for the end. It's that good.

But there's more: intelligent projections to include . . .

Many experts believe Africa, with its expansive base of newly minted consumers, may very well be on the verge of becoming the next India, thanks to frenetic urbanization and the sort of big push in services and infrastructure that transformed the Asian subcontinent 15 years ago.

The ending shines as well, as it cites continuing obstacles and reminds us that this area is very "frontier":

Still, Africa remains at the very frontier of emerging markets. Despite its gains, the difficulty and cost of running a business there are the highest in the world, according to data from the International Monetary Fund. Couple that with pervasive corruption--Transparency International calls the problem "rampant" in 36 of 53 African states--and it's no wonder Africa is often regarded as a toxic place to operate. But World Bank president Robert Zoellick says that in the aftermath of the economic crisis, long-term investors have recognized that "developed markets have big risks too." Like China and India, Africa is exploiting that fact, and perhaps more than any other region it is illustrative of a new world order in which the poorest nations will still find ways to steam ahead.

This is why, after I show the Gap in the brief, I shrink it down rapidly in a series of animations that suggest Africa will be the center of global integration going forward.

De-globalization, my ass. We're just entering a point of inflection on globalization's expansion. That's why creating Africom was so smart. No part of the system will exhibit more play in coming years--both good and bad.

12:51AM

China's success creates its own pushback--the globalization price

FRONT PAGE: "Congress letter urges US action on renminbi," by Daniel Dombey, Financial Times, 16 March 2010.

WORLD NEWS: "China presses US groups in protectionism dispute: Beijing calls on multinationals to flex their muscles as anger grows in Washington," by Geoff Dyer, Jamil Anderlini and James Politi, Financial Times, 17 March 2010.

FRONT PAGE: "Business Sours on China: Foreign Executives Say Beijing Creates Fresh Barriers; Broadsides, Patent Rules," by Andrew Browne and Jason Dean, Wall Street Journal, 17 March 2010.

Congress is getting pissed, and Obama needs to show toughness somewhere besides Afghanistan.

You can tell all this pressure is having impact if Beijing is begging multinationals to stand up and count their money. You can bet the lobbying is proceeding apace, but the dander has done got up among the Members.

The outcome is likely to disappoint. Even a 20% appreciation won't have much impact on our current account deficit, say most experts.

But it's clear that Wen's big lecture backfired big-time, especially his truly stupid line about America only pushing this issue to boost its exports. Good God man! Take Economics 101 and pull your head out of your rear!

But here's the larger problem for China: it is giving off a lot of defensive, anti-foreigner signals that tell foreign multinationals that they're less welcome. Understanding the desire to build up domestic flagship companies, China risks losing its primary defender in the West.

And that will result in more counter-protectionism from our side. Will this devolve into a trade war? Unlikely.

But it does signal that China's ascendancy has its limits. If China gets shut down to foreign companies, then the same will happen for those companies when they to abroad.

Resistance is inevitable.

12:41AM

Wolf: widening his target list

COMMENT: "China and Germany unite to weaken the world economy," by Martin Wolf, Financial Times, 17 March 2010.

Will bad ideas never die?

First we are subjected to Chimerica, which seems designed for immediate consumption because it's far too precious a bit.

Now, Wolf indulges his inner Ferguson and comes up with Chermany to describe the two biggest and most successful export-heavy economies on the planet.

Not a great one, except it encompasses much of the global imbalance equation and because both the Germans and the Chinese are excessively anal on the subject (Germany on Greece; China on the pegged yuan).

Not one of his better columns, but we all have those now and then.