The ideologues are not rational, and thus definitely should be sent packing once the serious SysAdmin work begins
Sunday, January 29, 2006 at 5:53PM
Thomas P.M. Barnett

ARTICLE: "Political thought not rational: Scans find subject fires brain's emotional centers in both liberals and conservatives," by Benedict Carey, New York Times, 29 January 2006, pulled from web.

ARTICLE: "Hurrican Investigators See 'Fog of War' at White House," by Eric Lipton, New York Times, 28 January 2006, pulled from web.


When politics enters the brain, the freaky-deaky portions are excited and the logic portions are left wanting. That lack of "cold reasoning" explains the Right's bizarro hatred of Clinton and the Left's bizarro hatred of Bush.


But it also explains, I would argue, what happens when you let the ideologues of any administration, like Doug Feith in DoD or Karl Rove in the White House hold too much power during important security transitions like the postwar occupation of Iraq or the postdisaster non-occupation of New Orleans. Let the ideologues hold sway, and the sheer logic of what should be done is often superceded but the emotional logic of what seems best or most safe for the administration. Naturally, the long-term harm that's done by such political short-term logic typically outweighs the temporary gain of such steps as declaring "mission accomplished" and taking the requisite photo ops.


And the danger is different at home versus overseas: abroad the politicos typically want too much control of what should be left to the military, while at home the politicos are typically too fearful of being bold with the military at exactly those moments when a pro-active approach yields the best outcome.


Fog of war ain't that hard. Fog of postwar and postdisaster? That's really hard.


But unless you authorize, there ain't no authority. Northcom is a command, not a political entity. And DHS is a political entity, not a commander of anything.


No, the military-market nexus needs its own bureaucratic center of gravity, and that's why I call for a Department of Everything Else.

Article originally appeared on Thomas P.M. Barnett (https://thomaspmbarnett.com/).
See website for complete article licensing information.