Mark ZenPundit Safranski beat Tom to the punch on criticizing William Lind's criticism of Tom's work.

In that post, Mark also linked John Robb's criticism of Tom: Contra Barnett. I'm most interested in pointing out Robb's work because it's so much more even-handed than Lind's. Furthermore, the comments get really good with Mark and Robb going back and forth constructively. We want to link rational discussions of Tom's work, including those viewpoints that disagree. Check it out.